In the world of Major League Baseball (MLB), few things stir up more controversy and debate than a player being “robbed” of a deserved accolade or recognition. For fans of the Los Angeles Dodgers, and particularly for those who admire the talents of Walker Buehler, this topic has sparked passionate discussions in recent years. But when we ask, “Who robbed Walker Buehler?” it’s not about a literal theft—it’s about a figurative one: has this young, gifted pitcher been denied the recognition and awards he rightfully deserves?
The Rise of Walker Buehler
Walker Buehler, a dynamic right-handed pitcher for the Dodgers, has been one of the most promising talents in MLB. Known for his electric fastball, impeccable control, and unshakeable poise in high-pressure situations, Buehler has steadily built a reputation as one of the game’s elite arms since his debut in 2017. He has shown exceptional ability in both the regular season and postseason, contributing significantly to the Dodgers’ success, including their 2020 World Series title.
Despite his contributions and undeniable talent, some argue that Buehler hasn’t received the full accolades he deserves. Whether it’s in terms of individual awards, media recognition, or even fan appreciation, the question lingers: is Buehler being overshadowed?
The Cy Young Snub
One of the most notable instances of this perceived “robbery” centers around the Cy Young Award, which is given to the best pitchers in both the American and National Leagues. In recent years, Buehler has consistently been among the top pitchers in the league. He has posted outstanding statistics—boasting a low ERA, high strikeout rates, and the ability to dominate even the best hitters.
Yet, despite his performance, Buehler has never won a Cy Young Award. The competition for the honor is always stiff, with pitchers like Jacob deGrom, Max Scherzer, and Clayton Kershaw often leading the pack in the National League. However, many believe that in certain seasons, Buehler was deserving of stronger consideration and, perhaps, even the trophy itself. The lack of a Cy Young award on his résumé is seen by some as a “robbery” of sorts, denying him the individual recognition that matches his contributions on the field.
All-Star Game Overlooks
Another point of contention for Dodgers fans is the number of All-Star appearances Walker Buehler has earned. While Buehler has made a few All-Star teams, there have been seasons where fans and analysts alike felt he was overlooked. The All-Star Game is meant to showcase the best and brightest stars in baseball, yet Buehler has sometimes been left out of the roster despite performances that were more than worthy of inclusion.
With the popularity of big-market players or pitchers who grab headlines with higher strikeout totals or more media-friendly personalities, Buehler may not always be the flashiest choice for casual fans. But among those who appreciate pure pitching skill and dominance, his exclusion from certain All-Star rosters feels like another instance of Buehler being unfairly robbed of his due.
Media Attention and Market Competition
In addition to awards and honors, Buehler’s overall media presence has also been a subject of debate. Playing for the Los Angeles Dodgers, one of the most storied franchises in baseball history, comes with a certain level of attention. However, Buehler is often in the shadow of other big names, even within his own team. Pitchers like Clayton Kershaw and offensive stars like Mookie Betts and Freddie Freeman often dominate the headlines, while Buehler quietly goes about his work.
This lack of media spotlight can contribute to the perception that Buehler isn’t receiving the full recognition he deserves. Though Buehler has a dedicated fanbase, especially among Dodgers fans, his profile on the national level isn’t always as high as some of his peers. Whether it’s his quiet demeanor or the presence of other superstar teammates, it can sometimes feel like Walker Buehler is being robbed of the attention that should naturally come with his level of performance.
Injuries: The Unfortunate Thief
Injuries have also played a role in derailing Buehler’s journey toward greater recognition. Pitching is a physically demanding role, and Buehler, like many other elite pitchers, has had to deal with his share of health setbacks. Tommy John surgery in 2022, a major elbow procedure for pitchers, sidelined him and has delayed his ability to consistently be on the mound. While injuries are a natural part of any athlete’s career, they have undoubtedly limited Buehler’s opportunities to cement his legacy further.
Every time Buehler has been forced to miss games or entire seasons, it can be seen as a robbery of the chance for him to add to his accolades and milestones. This has been particularly frustrating for fans who know that if Buehler were fully healthy, he would likely be contending for more Cy Youngs, All-Star appearances, and postseason glory.
Conclusion: A Legacy Still Unfolding
So, who robbed Walker Buehler? The answer might be a mix of factors—stiff competition, the spotlight of bigger names, injuries, and the unpredictable nature of baseball awards and media attention. What’s clear is that Buehler’s talent and potential are undeniable, and despite any perceived slights or snubs, his legacy as one of the game’s elite pitchers is still unfolding. Whether or not he secures a Cy Young or other individual honors in the future, Buehler’s contributions to the Dodgers and MLB will continue to be appreciated by those who truly understand the art of pitching.
In the end, while it might feel like Buehler has been “robbed” of certain accolades, his career is far from over, and there’s every reason to believe that he’ll have plenty more opportunities to add to his growing list of accomplishments.
